Big question for this afternoon. What is art and what isn’t? Is it totally subjective? Can we throw a jacket in the corner and call it art? Someone did, and they called it art.

How about a pile of rotten meat? A picture made of poop? Is there a line we can’t cross?

As a visual artist and art lover, I’m a fan of beauty.; the Impressionists, Van Gogh, Turner, Renaissance masterpieces… you get the idea. Art History tells us that most art we love now, even works like Monet’s water lilies that are now considered classics and perhaps even a little twee, were considered avant-garde, outrageous or in poor taste when they were created.

I still think there’s a line between experimentation and gross-out, a huge jump from pointillism to Piss Christ. A case of the sublime and the ridiculous.

But this is my opinion.

Many would disagree. In fact, lots of people, including me, will defend an artist’s right to make whatever they want. I just won’t go and look at it.

My personal “what is art” line is quite close to the conservative side of art. I’ll freely admit that.

Even so, I had a bit of a shock this week when I found out that 50 Shades is really very tame by some people’s standards and tastes.

I know, right?

Now, I don’t read erotica and have only read a few pages of EL James’ best seller but I’ve got nothing against it. Anything that gets people reading and “connecting” is good, right?

Is it art? I’m not so sure about that but the story involves consenting adult characters who aren’t doing anything illegal, so what the hell.

Of course, my idea of what is poor-taste is different from yours, and that of say my mum and dad, or the government of the People’s Republic of Pakistan. Libertarians will fight tooth and nail for the individual’s right to self-expression unfettered by the thought-police.

But what about stories that document sexual abuse of minors, domestic violence or incest? I’m not talking about crime stories with a villain and a cop, but a fiction work that portrays such crimes? I was stunned to find out that such works are apparently published online with an active following.

Then I was horrified to read a thread in which people from all over the world defended a writers ‘right’ to write whatever they want. It’s subjective, they said, art always is.

In my opinion, such works are as far from art as they could possibly be, and have no place in modern society.

Call me old-fashioned.

 

2 Replies to “What is art and what isn’t?”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

The Unseen Library

Expert reviews of the latest and the best in Fantasy, Historical Fiction, Science Fiction and Crime Fiction from an Australian reviewer.

jillwrites

Author of Dual Visions & Vashla's World, also co-author of Fan-tas-tic-al Tales and Mystery, Mayhem & Magic as one of The Ten Penners, I write book reviews, articles and other interesting prose.

thetenpenners.wordpress.com/

a collective of children's story writers

claire.she.goes

Content Writing

Doodlewash®

Adventures in Watercolor Painting and Sketching, Watercolour Magazine, with Charlie O'Shields

Awaiting the Muse

The Life of a Writer: Composed of waiting as much as writing.

A Book. A Thought.

“A room without books is like a body without a soul.” ― Marcus Tullius Cicero

Corey Truax

Husband | Father | Veteran | Author

Bookshelf

Explores the world through literature, movies, words, and quotes for the intellectually curious

Read Eat Sleep Repeat

A book review blog.

Marlena Marie

words come alive the moment you let them exist

Gershon Ben-Avraham

Writing is Remembering

NO LOVE LOCKS™

Free Your Love. Save Our Bridges.

half a purpose

Genuine Humble Kind

Wanderlusty Writer

I read. I write. I wander.

Travel with Intent

A photographer's view of the world - words and images to inspire your travels and your dreams

Spice and Sauce

Writing Kindle Erotica

%d bloggers like this: