“A point of view can be a dangerous luxury
when substituted for insight and understanding.”
— Marshall McLuhan, The Gutenberg Galaxy
Perhaps Marshall McLuhan was a time traveller. These prescient words were written more than fifty years ago when the black and white television was the only screen in most homes.
My dad used to tell jokes and always had a funny saying for every occasion. I suggested once that he keep an open mind about something. His response? “I don’t want an open mind, my brain might fall out.”
Sometimes I couldn’t tell if dad was joking because jokes are usually funny and well, this speaks for itself.
Joking aside, I was raised to listen, learn and fall in line. Questioning authority was something men were sometimes allowed to do, but only on rare occasions, but women? Never. The problem for me was that I question everything. It gets me into trouble.
I unearthed some old report cards this week. I was such a “pleasure to teach” apparently. That was until I found myself at a church-run school. My parents truly thought it best for us, even though I was happy and thriving at the local primary school. Instead of thriving, I can use those report cards to plot a course of self-destruction over the three years I was unfortunate enough to be stuck in that horrible school that hated me almost as much as I hated it. I burnt the evidence but I need to remember that there’s a reason for everything…? Isn’t there? If there’s no reason then at least I believe that nothing is wasted. I can forget the pain and hurt but I won’t forget the lesson learnt.
Oh, would that I had attended a Steiner school or the Green School in Bali (if they had one of those back then), or Hogwarts. sigh…(Although I’ve done the questionnaire and I would have been in Slytherin.)
I might have been a “pleasure to teach” as a wee girl but being at a school I hated and disagreed with made me into a disturbing element and taught me to ask “too many” questions. As I approach my mid-century, the last couple of years have seen me constantly having to confront and unlearn so many opinions and beliefs, some of which were so deeply held I was surprised to see them when they popped up, like an unfortunate outfit tucked at the back of the wardrobe that I’d forgotten about.
On the flip side, I’ve tried to teach my son to listen, learn, read, listen to someone else, read something different, learn some more, question, question, question! We need to question our opinions, our biases and our beliefs. Is it so bad to ask ourselves where these things come from? My church and school taught me that asking questions just gets you into trouble which is true, to be fair, but it’s worth it in the long run to have your mind, eyes, and heart opened.
Our minds are like children; they must be fed to grow and they will only grow on what we feed them. If we feed them garbage and waffle they will be stunted and petty. If we feed our minds on hate and cruelty, our thoughts cannot help but be hateful and cruel. If we close our minds and allow only what the damn algorithm lets through then we will be fed a steady diet of WHAT WE ALREADY KNOW, which tricks us thinking we know it all!
You know what they say about opinions?
All of us can benefit from an open-minded approach to learning but as writers and creatives especially, we owe it to ourselves to get outside of our circle of understanding and push ourselves to learn, to see things from another perspective. Stephen King says our first 1,000,000 words are garbage and I’d suggest that any number of words written by someone who refuses to read, to learn, to grow, will be garbage.
When asked if he thought the human race was evolving, Nobel Prize-winning author and teacher Elie Wiesel said it comes down to the individual to evolve. Same goes for peace, kindness, animal liberation, equality…
One last thing…
If you learn from me, just one thing it would be to think higher and feel deeper ~ Elie Wiesel
Gosh, what a wonderful post. It’s a humble thing to be continuously learning, and I’m so grateful you’re doing it out loud so I can benefit too 😊
You know, I’d never quite thought of the FB algorithm in those terms before. Friends’ opinions are well-acknowledged to create the echo chamber since we generally mix most with like minds, but I’d not considered how the algorithm makes the circle complete, nor how the mind might start to congratulate itself in the face of so little to challenge it.
Yet more evidence that FB is the literal digital equivalent of McDonald’s for the psyche – mostly gratification, formulated precisely to addict, and containing painfully little that will actually nourish.
Thank you for continuing to share. You’re wonderful!
Thank you for reading. It’s wonderful knowing I’m helping because you help me when I write these. Mostly I just imagine I’m talking to you when I blether on here 😉 Can you imagine if our grandparents watched only the news that supported their opinions? That’s called propaganda! Have you read Fahrenheit 451? I feel like people are living in one of their tv lined rooms. Truly frightening stuff.
Comments are closed.